Merry Litigation: All I Want for Christmas is a Copyright Infringement Lawsuit

Country singer Andy Stone, A.K.A Vince Vance, has renewed his lawsuit against Mariah Carey, which claims that her holiday hit 'All I Want for Christmas Is You' infringes the copyright of his song with the same name. Scott Hervey and Tara Sattler discuss this case on this episode of The Briefing. Watch this episode on the Weintraub YouTube channel here. Show Notes: Scott: Andy Stone, known professionally as Vince Vance, is suing Mariah Carey and Sony Music Entertainment for copyright infringement. Vance claims that the decades-old Christmas hit ‘All I Want for Christmas is You’ infringes his 1989 song ‘All I Want for Christmas is You.’ I'm Scott Hervey with Weintraub Tobin, and I'm joined today on this holiday edition of The Briefing by my partner Tara Sattler to discuss this Christmas-themed copyright infringement dispute on this next installment of The Briefing by Weintraub Tobin. So, Tara, I think nothing rings in the holiday like a good copyright infringement lawsuit. Tara: Yeah, who doesn't want to spend the holidays with their lawyers in court? Scott: I know I certainly do. So, Tara, according to the complaint, Stone and his co-writer Troy Powers claim that in 1989, they co-wrote a country music hit also titled ‘All I Want for Christmas is You.’ That song was recorded by Stone's band Vince Vance and the Valiants, and apparently, it went to number 23 on Billboard's Hot 100 airplay list. He claims that he has performed this song over 8000 times in concerts across 20 countries. He also claims that this song was licensed by Kelly Clarkson, who recorded her version of it in 2021. Tara: In the complaint, Stone alleges the unique linguistic structure of his song was copied and that his song is about a person disillusioned with expensive gifts and seasonal comforts, wants to be with their loved ones at Christmas, expresses that wish to Santa, and that the loved one and unnamed you standing under the Christmas tree would be a dream come true. Stone also identifies the phrase 'All I want for Christmas is You' as an element that was infringed. Lastly, the plaintiff claims that similarities in the melody support its claim. Scott: So, let's take a look at these claims and see how Carey and her team may respond and also how a court, right here in the Central District of California, may analyze the plaintiff's claims. So, as we know, a court will analyze the complaint by applying the extrinsic test, which, as we've discussed before, is used in the determination of substantial similarity. After the plaintiff has identified specific criteria that it alleges to have been copied, the court separates the unprotectable elements, such as facts or ideas, from those elements that are protectable. And then it sorts out whether there is enough similarities between the works as to the elements that are protectable, such that a reasonable jury could find that the defendant's work is substantially similar to the plaintiff's work. So, let's look at two of the elements the plaintiff identifies as being infringed: the linguistic structure and the phrase 'All I want for Christmas is You.' Tara: Sure? There are many songs that express the sentiment of wanting to be with a loved one during the Christmas season, and I can think of a few songs that draw on the theme of expressing wishes to Santa, such as Ariana Grande's 'Santa, Tell Me,' 'My Grown-Up Christmas List' by Amy Grant, and even 'Santa Baby' by Earth A. Kitt. Scott: That's right, and I suspect that Carrie's team will argue that ...